Father Brennan Burke's patience is tested when a woman shares that the Virgin Mary has appeared to her in his churchyard, and hordes of reporters converge on the scene. This pales in comparison to a talk show host who clashes with Burke the minute he arrives. When a body is found at the site, the talk show host is picked up for murder, and lawyer Monty Collins takes him on as a client. Monty and Brennan both have a stake in uncovering the truth. Problem is, they can't talk to each other about it, because one is bound by client confidentiality and the other by seal of confessional.